Trial and Failure

Scrutinizing r/WritingWithAI, and Having Mixed Feelings About It

As someone who is relatively outspoken about my concern with writing as a craft, and, consequently, my disdain for the encroachment of AI into that craft, a place like r/WritingWithAI is essentially anathema to me. It is a town square for those who either see writing as a commodity to be ruthlessly exploited with maximum possible efficiency or who have genuinely deluded themselves into believing that AI serves to enhance or supplement the creativity of writing, rather than strangle it. It is truly unpleasant to gaze upon.

But sometimes it's fun, so I will be gazing it upon it today.

I'll be examining a tutorial, entitled "How I write a 4-book saga with Claude (my full setup, step by step)", posted by someone tagged, with extreme and unwarranted generosity, as an "AI-assisted writer." A pattern you will notice is that most posts to this community which are longform and/or appear to have required actual effort are, often admittedly, themselves drafted by AI, because people who cannot string a plot together without outsourcing their thinking are absolutely not going to bother to try very hard telling people how to do it themselves.

The post begins with a very defensive disclaimer:

A quick note before anything else: If you don't like this workflow, or don't use AI this way to write your stories and about to comment “all that work when you could have just written it yourself,” this post isn’t for you, and that’s okay. Keep scrolling. This is for those of us who embrace writing with AI and want to get better at it.

Also, I write for myself. The only person I’m trying to please with my stories is me, and that’s all I care about. Yes, it’s work. I love the work.

The framing is immediate and important not to overlook: This post is for people who "want to get better at it." "Yes, it's work." This person is telling us how they write books, as if the credit ultimately belongs to them. They believe there is a craft being practiced and which it is possible to get better at. But by all accounts, including this one, "getting better" at writing with AI is to obfuscate that you have done so, to minimize its distinctive tells and fool the reader into believing that the output was written by a person. They essentially spell it out themselves later on:

3. Keep a list of banned habits, built from what you catch. Mine grows every time I spot a new tic. Some of the rules on my list (but no means all):

No em dashes

No “it wasn’t X, it was Y” sentences

No narrator explaining a feeling after the scene already showed it

No warm-up sentences announcing what’s about to be said

No vague verbs like go, come, get or make standing in for a specific action

No objects or buildings with feelings or a will of their own

Never state the theme out loud

Concrete sensory details and specific verbs

Your list will be different because your pet peeves are different. That’s good, because it’s your voice you’re protecting.

This person's own conceptualization of "getting better" at writing with AI is just to elide all of ways that people can tell that they didn't actually write it. "Your voice" here refers to whatever is required to deceive the reader, not some unique, artistically meritorious quality of the writer.

If this seems uncharitable, consider how little sense it makes otherwise. If your own personal, literary voice is what matters, even allowing AI to scaffold your writing is catastrophic to the artistic process. The poster mocks the idea that they "could have just written it themselves," but provides no actual counter to the objection. You cannot involve AI in your writing, much less let it draft your writing for you, and then claim that your goal is to "protect your voice," just as you cannot dive headfirst into a deep well and then claim that your goal is to keep your clothes dry. The action you have taken is directly counter to the goal you pretend to have, and so rather than putting in effort to refine and express your voice, you end up putting in effort to wring it from slop that originated outside of your own mind. (That is, of course, generously presuming that these people actually put in much effort to "protect their voice" after all.) This is a veritable efficiency disaster, just as attempting to fix a house with a bad foundation is far harder than building it correctly in the first place. If you're concerned about your voice, writing with AI requires more effort than just writing on your own.

This is why pleas about how writing with AI is itself a craft which these people "love" and "want to get better at" ring so hollow. These motivations do not actually justify or explain this use of AI, and there is no way to make it all fit together. Even if you grant that there do exist comprehensible artistic motivations for writing with AI, the ones provided in this post cannot fit the bill, just as you can justify photography as an art form, but not by appealing to how digital cameras help you preserve the texture of your brushstrokes.

In this case, it is also extraordinarily hard to believe that the trite "I only do this for me!" argument is being made genuinely. Perhaps it is just a failure of my own imagination, but I cannot conceive of how the specificity of producing a "four-book saga" evinces anything other than a goal to market whatever the AI outputs. This person has, or at least believes they have, put a lot of thought into their slop-creation pipeline. They clearly feel a lot of misplaced pride about it. There is no way this output is not being shoveled onto Amazon in an effort to squeeze some pennies that would otherwise go to authors who actually put time and heart into their creations.

It quickly becomes farcical. I certainly won't countenance any claims of "loving the work" and "protecting their voice" when the first tip they share is about how even supplementary brainstorming documents don't need to be touched by human hands:

You don’t have to build anything yourself. Ask Claude to make your story bible, character sheets, rules and dashboard with you.

AI is at the helm from start to finish, with nary a crumpled dinner napkin covered with errant scribbles to show for any human creativity. Only a hollow reassurance that they're written "with you" stands to guard against the obvious conclusion, which is that if you can't be bothered even to supply the story bible and character sheets by yourself, the information inside comes from the bot, not the person.

You make every story decision. Claude flags questions and pushes back, and you rule.

A common defense of writing with AI is that the human is actually in charge, using AI as a mere assistant or co-writer. But, again, this presupposes that there is a genuine human voice intact by the end of the process, and I just don't buy it. This person cannot be bothered to write a Reddit post about it; what credibility is there behind the idea that they put in the effort to wrench narrative and literary control from the machine, especially given, as I said, that doing so would take more effort than writing from scratch?

Even if we suppose that this is true, it's still inaccurate to claim that this person deserves the credit of authoring whatever slop results. There is more to writing than just being presented with a premade draft and then using your vibes to judge if it's groovy or not. That is not "you ruling"; that is you delegating. If you gave this person the same general plot of the book and had them write it, actually write it by themselves, the result would be profoundly different than what the AI produces. Every plot point, every line of dialogue, every digression and refinement and redraft, would come from within, not without. This isn't even up for debate when both co-writers are humans; it would be absurd to write a book collaboratively with someone and then claim that you alone deserve credit for it. So at best, and being more charitable than this person has demonstrated themselves to deserve, they still cannot claim to "rule" the writing process. At most they must cede their rule equally to the slop machine, and then leave it up for readers to argue about which one they think did most of the actual work, presumably hoping that none of them stumble across this tutorial, which basically spells it out.

A lot of you asked how I set things up and how I get Claude to write like a person. I figured this might help. This is my personal method and by no means the only way to do this, but this works very well for me and might work well for you. Here’s everything in one place. It looks like a lot written out, but Claude built most of it for me.

This person ostensibly cares about putting in the work to "get better" at writing with AI, but cannot be bothered even to draft the Reddit tutorial themselves. There is no world in which this post suggests an inclination toward hard work and self-edification.

Anyway, most of this will be skipped, because it's not worth anyone's time to read through slop whose own "author" couldn't be bothered to slap out, but there are some choice excerpts to examine:

I ask for pushback and its honest opinion. I want Claude to tell me when it thinks an idea is weaker, and I want to win some of those arguments too. If your partner agrees with everything, you’re writing alone. I also ask what it thought of a scene, not just whether it followed the rules.

This might reveal an underlying misconception behind this person's behavior: They appear to believe that the AI is capable of thinking for itself. Claude does not think. It has no thoughts about the scene. This person presents this solicitation of feedback as a useful check for quality, but that cannot come from a machine like Claude. Asking for its "thoughts" about how a scene reads is akin to asking a magic eight ball whether your character development is believable, and just as reliable. If the AI tells you that it "thinks" the scene is sloppy somehow, all you have to do is chastise it and it'll change its tune immediately. It's more suggestible than a toddler. Its feedback does not and cannot mean anything valuable because it's not founded upon any actual observations, principles, or critical thinking. This isn't merely a pedantic objection about using the word "think" to describe what the AI does; this is an objection about knowing AI doesn't think and treating its "thoughts" as more or less equal in constructive value to those of a human. You could ask the AI to passionately argue about why a scene is great, and then get it to turn around and passionately argue about why the same scene is terrible. Its feedback means nothing. There is nothing underneath, and so there isn't actually an argument being had to win.

The backstory gets written first, privately. Before drafting a chapter, Claude jots down what’s going on under the scene: what each character is hiding, what happened off the page. Very little of it makes it into the chapter, but you can feel it there. A lot of the restraint in my chapters comes from this.

Even the subtext is offloaded to the AI. It's not terribly clear what "restraint" refers to here, but assuming it refers to some of the deeper, subtext-driven feelings and vibes that the story elicits in the reader, it should be shocking to anyone who actually cares about writing that even this is surrendered.

We watch for patterns across chapters. Claude checks how the last few chapters ended so it doesn’t end five in a row the same way. Its favorite default was a quiet hand gesture, lol. We caught it.

"We caught it." Not "I caught it." This person did not read through the story and catch it themselves. They had to be told by the AI that the pattern existed, because keeping track of subtle, multi-chapter details like that requires more effort than someone who asks AI to write their Reddit posts is going to expend.

At time of writing, there are two comments left on this post. The first one is based:

My mind boggles at just how bad the resulting "Writing" must be.

The second one is cringe, and also rather confusing:

For the three-to-four chapter handoff, save two lines of approved dialogue per viewpoint. Read the first new scene aloud against them to catch voice drift. Automated AI comment.

I don't know why someone would read this post (or, more likely, direct their AI to read it) and then ask an AI to draft a two-sentence response. I just can't fathom the reason why you would do this. Upvote farming? At least they allowed their bot to be honest about who wrote it.

Most posts on the subreddit are characterized by this blend of arrogance, defensiveness, lack of self-awareness, and unwarranted self-aggrandizement. And, as mentioned, the longer posts are almost always written by AI themselves. They are, sometimes, rather funny in a grim sort of way, like this post, which serves as the AI-slop table of contents for ten even lengthier AI-slop posts which lament how even the AI slop purveyors are frustrated at how sloppy their slop is. It would surely take hours to read through it all, but why would anyone bother? Even the person who posted it admits that it's worthless, but attempts to justify their (minimal) effort by appealing to some vague future where AI historians (that's historians which are AI, not historians of AI) will pull it all from the depths of their training data and gather some sort of "insight" from it:

I don't expect that people will read this in entirety. It's too dense. However in the future, AI assisting people in this area - and it's going to happen, trust me on that - will refer back to this historical examination and provide further insight, and I hope it may be of use to other researchers that use AI writing tools in the future with their own endeavors.

This is, in other words, an AI writing for current AI so that future AI writing about past AI will know why then-current AI sucks so much.

At a certain point, I just get my fill, and it turns from amusing to disgusting, such as when, underneath that AI-written post, someone else's AI leaves a comment, which the original AI responds to. It's just two AIs talking to each other. Why? To what end? Neither of the humans behind the accounts are going to bother reading any of this, even, perhaps especially, the slop their own AI wrote. Who is this conversation for?

Posts like these lend me some reassurance that, maybe, AIs as we've built them won't ever make human-authored writing obsolete. Stories of actual quality and emotional depth require reflection on the world, an inner voice, and an understanding of how people act and think and feel. They require awareness of the species, but also awareness of the self. And if there is one thing these people lack more than writing ability, it's self-awareness.

#AI #anti-intellectualism #culture #technology